Re: The Imprinting Theory!!!
Posted: Sun Apr 19, 2009 3:48 am
Hi Max and fellow members,
I did indeed enjoy Ripley's book, but I wouldn't call it a gospel. I was going to point out that there are two environments involved in this matter, the internal and external environ-
ment. The internal environment could play a big role in the turning off and on of genes.
I am speculating, but the turning on and off of the genes may not be as exacting as we
believe. I, like you, believe that genetics has some role to play in determining behavior. Consider how they treat mental illness today. Many conditions, like manic depression and even paranoia, are treated with drugs that control the behavior. This is an indication that there is a chemical inbalance in the body. If this is not a chemical inbalance caused by some external modification,then the genes, which makes all the chemicals in the body, must be responsible to some degree.
We might also consider the fact that two very young people could watch a movie that contains the death of one or more women. One would not be affected by it ,while the other could develop a death fetish. The likihood of this being purely the external environment is very unlikely to me.
I must say that this has been a very interesting topic with good submissions by all
involved.
Max- Thank you for your book suggestions, I will be checking them out. As you pointed out, there is much to be learned in this area and new information is discovered
each day.
Sincerely Kevin 67
I did indeed enjoy Ripley's book, but I wouldn't call it a gospel. I was going to point out that there are two environments involved in this matter, the internal and external environ-
ment. The internal environment could play a big role in the turning off and on of genes.
I am speculating, but the turning on and off of the genes may not be as exacting as we
believe. I, like you, believe that genetics has some role to play in determining behavior. Consider how they treat mental illness today. Many conditions, like manic depression and even paranoia, are treated with drugs that control the behavior. This is an indication that there is a chemical inbalance in the body. If this is not a chemical inbalance caused by some external modification,then the genes, which makes all the chemicals in the body, must be responsible to some degree.
We might also consider the fact that two very young people could watch a movie that contains the death of one or more women. One would not be affected by it ,while the other could develop a death fetish. The likihood of this being purely the external environment is very unlikely to me.
I must say that this has been a very interesting topic with good submissions by all
involved.
Max- Thank you for your book suggestions, I will be checking them out. As you pointed out, there is much to be learned in this area and new information is discovered
each day.
Sincerely Kevin 67